1852 Grill Room

This place is highly recommended if your on the island. We both got steaks with cream style corn and mashed potatoes. They knocked it out of the park. We sat outside and enjoyed the view. Its a classy place and hats are not allowed. We will be back in summer of 2026 for sure.

The food- exceptional. The porterhouse steak was so very well seasoned & prepared. My wife had a skirt steak served over a Caesar salad which was very much to her satisfaction. Service is warm, personal, & professional. Kieth was our waiter for the dinner meal & Jacqueline was our breakfast waitress. Both of these individuals deserve a significant shout-out for their service. Additionally, Jeff, whom I believe is the restaurant manager. He also needs accolades - on this day, this upscale restaurant was to also serve 100+ elementary children in a buffet style service. Jeff was able to see that our reservation was at a time where the ambiance would have been "different". Jeff was able to reach out to us & move our reservation to an alternate time & maintain the relaxing & romantic dinner we

Do yourself a favor and go here for dinner. Everything was exceptional. Had the crab cake starter. Tons of crab meat! The special summer salad was very good. Filet super tender. Potatoes and Mac -n-cheese were great. And the carrot cake for dessert was truly one of the best I’ve ever had and it’s my favorite so I’ve had it a lot! Service great. View great. And to top it off we had a dinner voucher from our hotel. Paid $90 and got nearly double that in value. Just do it!!

We had a salad, shared a filet and skirt steaks. Loved the Caesar salad. Filet was overcooked but still decent. Skirt was good. My gf claims the Cosmo was the best she's ever had. I really did not like the seating arrangements as they are too close to others, very cafeteria style though some tables are spaced out better.

We will come back to the island for this restaurant. The ambience, views and food. Truly more memorable than many top restaurants I’ve visited in Europe or our major US cities. Go! Get the bread plate with custom butter and roasted garlic, the whitefish or the filet. We went two nights in a row because it was really that good.