2 PaiZan’s Pizzeria Cucina

2 PaiZan's is City Island's own bronx style pizzeria. With a rotating selection of limited topping and specialty pies, 2 PaiZan's is a MUST-stop-slice-shop for anyone traveling to or residing within the City Island confines. In addition to the pies, 2 PaiZan's offers a range of other interesting and delicious options, from bureks to cheesecakes, pepperoni rolls to full blown catering trays, and 3/6ft heroes to fries and garlic knots. Great space for small parties or solo eaters. Eat-in, take-out or delivery options. Remember as times change (and tariff insanity ensues) so do food prices, so be sure to check in with your server for the latest pricing information. Friendly service and warm facilities round out your experience at 2 PaiZan's. No parking lot, but on-street spots abound. Just go

A Hidden Gem on City Island! I rarely write reviews, but 2 PaiZans Pizzeria deserves all the praise—and more! From the moment you walk in, you can feel the pride, culture, and heart behind this family-run spot. The staff treats you like you’re part of the family, and the food? Next level. Their pizza is perfectly crisp with a chewy crust and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. You can taste the tradition in every bite. But don’t stop at the pizza—try the burek or the Albanian-style dishes. It’s not often you find a pizzeria serving such a unique mix of Italian and Balkan flavors—and doing it so well. The sandwich was a knockout, and the strawberries with chocolate and pistachio was the perfect finish. It’s clear they put love into everything they do, and that love shows. Clean, w

2 PaiZans is an absolute hidden gem on City Island! Their Italian–Albanian cuisine is insanely good — the Sicilian pizza is perfectly crisp and fluffy with rich, flavorful toppings, and the special-order cheese marinara burek pie is nothing short of legendary. It’s a tiny (mostly take-out) shop, but the food packs an incredibly big punch! Every bite felt like flavor perfection — comforting, bold, and just unforgettable. The team is friendly and welcoming, and the passion for great food really shows. If you’re in the area and haven’t tried 2 PaiZans yet, drop everything and go. You’ll be so glad you did! 🍕🔥👏

I recently visited 2PaiZan’s, and it was an absolutely fantastic experience—easily a five-star! The pizza and Burek I ordered was phenomenal: perfectly crispy crust, rich and flavorful sauce, and fresh, high-quality toppings that made me do my happy wiggly dance with every bite lol. The food was definitely the highlight; you can really taste the care and attention in every bite. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it a great spot to relax and enjoy a great meal. The service was attentive and friendly, which made the entire visit even better. I highly recommend 2PaiZan’s to any pizza and burek lover looking for a top-notch experience!

They do have really good pizza. They use quality products. Recently they are making their in-house pies larger so they can charge more per slice, personally I think $4 for a reg slice is too much but I will pay it. I ordered a small pie. The size of the slices are perfect for a 3 year old. I don't think I'll order anymore small pies.