440 Pizzeria

I love 440 but for some reason my wings are never right. Even after they assured me they are. I trust them so I never open it up before I go to check and then I get home and I’m disappointed. I asked for extra crispy extra wet sticky wings and they are always dry. I walk there so walking back to correct an order when I’m hungry doesn’t seem logical.

I like the pizza there. I always get the baked ziti slice, however, today I called like normal and was answered by a rude kid. He was treating me some sort of way because I asked him if they had the big ziti slice considering I wasn't there and couldn't see for myself. I've ordered from here multiple times and I've never had that kind of disrespect before. You can just tell he was pissed and didn't even want to take the order, talking to me like I'm dumb or something. The food is good but will not be going back due to this.

I want to give this place more stars...however they are sacrificing quality for quantity. Canned mushrooms still wet. Meat lovers was a disappointment. PROS: -Good for highschoolers -family deal -Great Garlic Knots! CONS: -Quality (soggy, flavorless) -Small restaurant

Edit: The shop responded defensively, calling this a fake review. I assure you I'm a real person with over a million views on Google Reviews. I had hoped they would take the criticism and improve their pizza, but that doesn't seem to be happening. Sorry. This was one of the worst slices I've ever had. I waited a week to write this. It's my easy for me to write bad reviews. I hate doing it. But this pizza was really really bad. If the shop changes their recipe and changes their pizza, and then comments to me that they did this, I will remove this review. But they have to change it up. It was horrible. They should go down the block to the slice shop and see how they do it. I'm writing this because this place has to change. Sorry.

440 knocked it out of the park again with their quintessential NY pie. I immediately seek out this place as soon as I arrive from TN to visit my family because I know they will have exactly that pizza I wish I could find at home. Staff always treats us as family and cooks their food with pride. Keep it up guys.