Allstar Pizza and More

This was a fun little find. We traveled from Denver and Utah to beach over thanksgiving break and looked for fun experience away from the beach. We had 10 hungry teenagers and we loved this little place. Great price for the amount of food. And the pizza was actually good for a “buffet” place. It included drink, pizza, simple salad, 1 dessert pizza and “calzone” style pizza. The staff were so friendly and accommodating. It’s in a cozy dark corner off the main street. Definitely worth going to. Buffet hours differ from the regular hours.

Was our first time to the place the other day. I grew up going to this small pizzeria and it reminded me of that. From the smell of dough to the heat from all the ovens baking. Pizza was amazing I even ate the crust. We were there for a party and the Arena in the back was great for the children. I have 4 total at different age ranges and they had stuff for all of them to do. We live out of town but will drive that hour to go back soon.

Ordered the Sportsplex Madness with extra sauce. It barely had sauce on it and the toppings were chopped fine and spread thinly over the pizza. The overall pizza lacked flavor. The (8) piece boneless wings consisted of two regular size wings and remaining were small (very) small pieces. All of this added up to $42 which it was definitely not worth it. I DO NOT RECOMMEND ALLSTAR. OVER PRICED AND POOR QUALITY. (I do not know where the good reviews would come from.)

I love this place! Great staff, patient, kind, never hurried -even remember your name if you walk or call in. The pizza's are delicious but the deserts are chef's kiss. My favorite is the apple cinamon canzone- perfection even the day after...if you dont eat it all first night. And price is reasonable. Highly recommend.

My daughter came in visiting from Austin and wanted All Star specifically the calzone. Kalen took our order he was very friendly and helpful. Lex gave us order and also was very friendly. Best experience I’ve had at a restaurant lately and it was much needed. The food was amazing and we will definitely continue to visit All Star!