Andrew’s Diner

This place is a gem . One of the best diners left on Staten Island . Food was good and the two specials we got for the day were excellent. I got the roasted chicken with baked potato and vegetable. Cream of Turkey soup and salad. My husband got the broiled salmon with sweet potato and mixed vegetables. Cream of Turkey soup and salad as well . We both got desert with our meal. Cheesecake and chocolate mouse cake . Can’t wait to go back again.

I totally recommend this place! The food was really good — like, really tasty. My boyfriend and I ordered a burger and the Cuban sandwich, and we were both completely full afterward. One thing that mattered to me was whether they serve real maple syrup with the Belgian waffles — and they do! Big win for me. As for the place itself, it's super clean and well-kept, kind of a classic diner vibe. It was just really nice to be there. Another plus — they let us take all the butter from the table to go, which was a small thing but still appreciated. The total for the two of us came out to $50, which I think is pretty reasonable.

Best fish ‘n chips in town! Food is amazing and portion is big! Friendly staff and cozy atmosphere. It’s nice to have such great diner in the neighborhood.

I’m a professional videographer and I travel to various places across the United States, filming and often dining at different establishments. It’s rare for a place to truly impress me, but I was blown away by the delicious pastrami and the outstanding service. I absolutely loved everything. I highly recommend this place — it’s impeccable, with flawless service and great prices.

Went here on Good Friday 2025 for breakfast. Chose this since it had high ratings and we were visiting Staten Island. It’s a regular diner. Nothing fancy but it works. Good menu selection. I liked the vegetable omelette. My husband was not thrilled about the eggs benedict with salmon and expected better taste. I expected better waffles somehow. Not great but decent food. Seems like many locals come here. Decent service. Their restaurant signage could use some repair. Since parking was limited, you can opt for street parking.