Anthony's Paninoteca

Got the godfather hero, pasta salad, and a cream soda. The cream soda was really good and vanillay! The pasta salad was also very good. The hero was massive and a bit too fatty for me but really good quality meats and cheeses and good sandwhich overall just might try something different next time

Oh my god. This sandwich is something special(The A.G.V). I’ve had a few of their sandwiches and each one was delicious. Great ingredients, very large sandwiches filled to the gills. The bread is perfectly tender without being too crispy but strong enough to keep all the ingredients inside and not be soggy. Can’t wait for the other location to get more options like this location.

Got the sandwich for doordash cuz I'm all the way up in the North shore... so I can't really judge the atmosphere and the service but I'm thinking they deserve a five-star for it anyway. I'm a big guy I'm a fat boy and I got to tell you this was one of the best sandwiches I ever had in my life I live in the North shore and it's difficult for me to come down there but dude I finally splurged on the PANINO MORTADELLA These are not sandwiches these are gourmet meals! Thank you for such an amazing meal my friends and especially to you Antonio! it's a good thing you're not too close to me or I'd be like 600 pounds lmao!! Best of luck in the future, like you need it lol!

I catered from Anthony’s for my families Christmas party and it was outstanding! The mini sandwich platter was a hit with its assortment of savory combos for everyone and the potato croquettes and rice balls were the perfect side dish. Love this place and look forward to catering from them in the future.

Visiting Staten Island we stopped at Paninoteca and I gotta tell ya the Porchetta Sandwich blew my mind. Roasted Italian pork, smoked mozzarella, broccoli robe and a delicious crusty roll made this one of the best sandwiches I’ve eaten in quite a long time. If I’m ever in Staten Island again I’m gonna visit this shop and bring my friends and family cause it’s that Good!