Antietam Dairy

Fantastic pumpkin ice cream to start off the fall season! Lots of people still asking for ice cream in these early days of September. Found Spidey hanging around and Captain America! Super friendly and nice staff. Definitely give Antietam dairy to thumbs up!

Homemade ice cream off the beaten path. Window service and cash only. We asked for a taste of two flavors and were given a generous almost-teaspoon-full even though I asked for “a lot less” after she handed the first generous taste. Coffee is always my to-go flavor and their version was mild and not to my liking. Neither was the double- chocolate which did not have a lot of chocolate flavor. I decided to risk a small cup of blueberry cheesecake without a pre-taste. VERY bland. Same with my partner’s strawberry cheesecake. No doubt about its creaminess and minimal aeration. It definitely is premium ice cream. It would have been rude to keep tasting to pick a flavor that had actual flavor. The two we picked unfortunately did not have much.

Fantastic ice cream at a good price. They offer a wide variety of flavors, and are positioned within convenient walking distance of a beautiful hillside cemetery. However, I will give them one critique, being that their menu changes far too frequently, with certain flavors coming in and out of rotation, given whatever is in stock that day. While this does allow them to have dozens of flavors, they only have around 30 at any given time, so whether or not your favourite will be available comes down to a cointoss. If you're okay with switching up your order each time you go for ice cream, Antietam is the best place in town to grab a cone.

Antietam Dairy supplies ice cream for our bike event every year. They are the best!! The ice cream is homemade and super delicious! Everyone LOVEs the ice cream and it is a highlight of our event to have their truck at the finish.

Not sure who you had at Penn Mar Park on Sunday August 10 but I’d like to say he is the friendliest and quickest guy to get orders out to customers. And I’d like to thank him for the service he provided !!! Also LOVE your Grapenut ice cream !