Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks

20/10 ⭐Antonella’s Pizzeria on Fairbanks is a hidden gem. I grabbed a Too Good To Go bag and was thrilled — a full order of buttery garlic knots with tangy marinara and two fresh, cheesy slices of pizza. Everything was garlicky, delicious, and clearly made with care. Friendly staff, super easy pickup, lots of parking, and a small outdoor seating area. It’s a cozy family-owned pizzeria has heart and absolutely worth supporting. Definitely my new go-to pizza spot.🍕

First time eating here on 12/31/25, Kekes across the street recommend this place. Well it didn’t disappoint! Got two slices of pizza with cheese only and a regular salad. Pizza tasted great, a little oily but lots of flavor! Salad was also good and fresh. Emily was our server, loved her positive attitude and smile. She greeted me and my friend when we walked in. Asked how we were doing and got our food in less than 10 minutes. Will come again! Thank you Emily for the positive experience! A++

As I told the crew last night, this was the best pizza I’ve had in the last five years! The pie and crust were absolutely perfect, the sauce tasted natural and truly homemade, and the anchovies (a family favorite) were incredibly flavorful. On top of that, the staff was friendly and welcoming. Great place, easy parking, fair pricing, and most importantly: AMAZING PIZZA!!! 🍕

Pizzeria Antonella in Fairbanks Ave. Winter Park, delivered an absolutely unforgettable experience. The owner personally took our order, and his kindness, warmth, and willingness to accommodate made all the difference. From the very first interaction, his hospitality was truly exceptional. The pizza was simply delicious—perfectly made, full of flavor, and clearly prepared with care and passion. It was the highlight of our office celebration as we enjoyed it while celebrating our boss’s birthday, and it could not have been more perfect. The delivery to our office was smooth and timely, and the delivery person was extremely respectful and professional, which we truly appreciated. This was not just great pizza—it was a wonderful experience built on quality, generosity, and genuine care. H

This is the absolute BEST Italian restaurant we have ever been too. (And we have been to quite a few!) - The cooking was AMAZING but best of all our server, Nick, was truly remarkable!! Once we expressed how happy and amazing the food was he even brought the chef out and we were able to meet and thank him. They truly made us feel as if we were part of the family. If you want an authentic experience with a loving team, go to Antonella’s. We will definitely be back next Sunday. ❤️ I cannot express enough how wonderful of an experience we had. Side note: our kids had pizza and me and my husband had the pastas. EVERYTHING was delicious. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! Thank you Nick and team for being incredible!