Bagel Supreme

I have been going here for a month now on the weekends Not sure what the other reviews have complained about I see the same older man there with a lazy eye and he is always super nice and friendly, maybe owner? I love seeing this guy, genuinely warms my heart to come here and get a bagel from him. My girlfriend has been obsessed with bagels from NYC and NJ and even she says this is the best bagel she's had. Soft and standard but then the other crust isn't super crunchy or crispy but has that nice hard cracking exterior that changes up from the soft inside. I saw reviews about the cream cheese being too soft? Yeah it's smeared onto a toasted bagel, it melts a bit, I love that actually. If you want cold basically solid cream cheese then just go buy it from a grocery store. Rainbow Bagel w

Love everything about Bagel Supreme! The owner and all of the workers have a great attitude and are all super friendly and dedicated. Yes, the prices went up (just as they did EVERY WHERE), but the high quality of all of their foods never went down. Great breakfast wraps, bagels, and sandwiches. Their fridge is always fully stocked with juices, water, Gatorade etc. And there is always fresh coffee. They also have homemade muffins that are delicious!

Was excited to try this place, sadly was disappointing. When I went almost everyone behind the counter seemed pretty young, I thought that was great to see young teens/ adults working so that's a plus. Now to food , bagel with scallion cream cheese, one look , I could tell this was a loss. The cream cheese was so oily and runny it was like melted butter. To be fair I tasted it with my finger, never again. Now on to the sandwich which had the strongest onion odor. I took it out of bag and damm. The onions were expired for sure. Again to be fair I picked out onions and tried sandwich, I couldn't stomach it the taste was very off. So now both my orders were trashed, wasted money. Sorry it's a no for me.

I had to listen to the owner/manager nastily yelling at his staff the entire time I was there this morning. I was embarrassed for them. He wasn't even friendly to the customers. Prices have gone up since I was last there earlier this year and amount of product used has gone down. I ordered a cheese sandwich and it had only 4 small slices of cheese. Another customer decided to add to his initial order and the owner kept ignoring him. My advice is to wear ear plugs if you go there.

There's a million bagel spots in NJ but tried this one on a whim and we will definitely be trying to go back! Bagels are delicious and they don't put excessive cream cheese like most places do. I also ordered an egg sandwich which was one of the best I've had (although they ran out of round rolls so I settled for a hero). They also have gluten-free cookies if you have to avoid wheat. Parking can be tricky at busy times but there is additional parking around the back of the building.