Baldy's Pizzeria

We've been teaching my 6-year old to be polite about food even when he doesn't like it. He ate one piece of this pizza and looked at me and said dead serious, "The next time we go here, I'll ask them to put some salt on it." Yall, something is off when my 6-year old doesn't like the pizza. I quite agreed with him, the crust was pretty flavorless. Even the sausage was kind of flavorless. One time I was counting calories and I overcooked some sausage on purpose and drained all the fat off and even dried it with a paper towel to get rid of all the fat. This sausage pizza reminded me of that. Maybe they've changed the formula to reduce the calories? Or they just overcooked the sausage that day?

New to town and wanted pizza from a small family and not commercial so, Baldy’s was it. It arrived as a fully cooked pepperoni pizza with loose peppers, sausage, mushrooms just tossed on top. 🤷‍♂️ Everything was falling off because it sat loose on top of the cheese and not to mention how violently ill I was the next morning from 2 slices. Go to Kroger next door and get Totino’s…. it’s better.

The pizza was decent, but ZERO excuse for serving a side salad like this. It makes me question the freshness of each of their toppings. If you're gonna let a cheap head of iceberg go bad, then what would keep you from serv8ng something else that's clearly a few days past the expiration date. I was totally bummed. After reading reviews, I was actually looking forward to trying this place. 3 stars only cuz pizza was okay and side salad was 3.00 ... but still I door dash, and that side salad took me a half hour to earn...

Our first time, and was unpleasantly surprised by the size of a “large” pizza at $21+ dollars. The pizza was good, but the size of the large pizza is really the size of a medium pizza. With the volume of good pizza joints around, it’s not worth the price and we won’t be returning. They should consider less quantity of toppings, and offset it with more dough (dough is cheep) to make the pizza size a true large.

New location, same great food! Always count on pizza to be delicious and breadsticks are our favorite. Best stromboli in town hands down! Prices are fair and staff is always super nice.