Best Pizza in Cape May Court House | My Pizza Heaven

I should have taken pictures before we started to eat but I didn’t plan on doing a review. The pizza wasn’t good. It Was very floppy, the crust had no crunch and the pizza itself tasted basic and bland. The chicken was good and the frys were good. The cheesesteak wasn’t the best either. The service was horrible! Probably the worst I’ve had in awhile . Sat there for awhile and no1 asked if we needed booster seats for our 2 toddlers so I had to look around and find 2 for myself. The waitress gave us 2 waters for the toddlers but no straws so I had to look for them myself also. When she brought our food out she put a steaming hot cheesesteak right infront of the 2 toddlers and they instantly tried to grab at it. She also didn’t bring out plates for us so I had to find those myself also ( ther

I stopped in around 6:45 pm to grab a couple slices of pizza. The dining area was kind of dirty and there was one employee folding boxes on the table. So I took it out to eat in my car. The slices were old, floppy, greasy beyond words and absolutely disgusting. I took the second slice back in to show them how bad it was ( it literally had a hole right in the center of it and it stuck to the wax paper). They said they would give me another slice but I was disgusted. If you can’t serve fresh pizza that you would want to eat yourself the. Don’t be in business. I’ll never go back there as long as I live. Wish I had the foresight to take a picture of the slop they gave me.

BE WARNED! terrible. only order fresh here, if you have to eat here. pizza looked several hours old, so we ordered a fresh pie. it's a step up from a dominos, not your typical Jersey slice. we ordered the potato wedges and they stunk of old rancid oil. the guys smelled it and thought there was nothing wrong with it. my girls and mother both smelled it. unbelievable that they denied it. you cant be a restaurant owner and not know what rancid oil smells like. that behavior right away shows you what kind of values they have. then they refund me without tax. no apologies, no service, nothing. EDIT: my girls and mother had an upset stomach later that night and multiple trips to the bathroom. I wasnt feeling great either. this restaurant is being ran terribly and without any care or pride in wh

They have a chicken special 12 pieces of dark for 14.99. My husband stopped in and they told him 32.00. He questioned them and they said that they no longer run that special and that they haven't removed it from their website. They wouldn't even honor the price since it was still posted so he walked out. Horrible way to tun a business.

Some of the best margarita pizza I have tasted. The (honey hot) buffalo chicken pizza is yummy too. Crust is decent, 8.5 out of 10. Plain, pepperoni, and supreme pizzas are pretty good too. Margarita is their best. Oh, the grandma’s Sicilian is pretty good too. The honey butter biscuits are delicious, but their salad is basic. My chicken Caesar was lettuce and cheese with a little chicken and they gave me prepackaged ranch after asking what dressing I wanted when I requested Caesar. I can’t recommend a cheesesteak from here- wrong roll they had AC (hard dense crunchy) not Philly style(soft light chewy)- iykyk. Good place if you want pizza, (dad also likes their fried chicken but I haven’t tasted it).