Big Pie In the Sky Pizzeria

We Finally found the Absolute Closest Slice Of Pizza To Authentic NY Style..Crispy,Sicilian Fold ! We had the Lunch Special: A Slice ( and believe me it’s enough!!) their Slices are GIGANTIC!! 2 Toppings and a Drink $5.95 free refills! Pizza was Delicious..We will be back !!

Big Pie in the Sky in Kennesaw, Georgia, is hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Having visited New York City and tried some of the best slices there, I can confidently say this pizza tastes like it came straight from New York. I remember they had another location in the Roswell/Alpharetta area, but it closed during COVID — truly a shame since it was closer to home in Norcross. Despite the drive from Norcross, every bite was worth it. The crust, sauce, and toppings are perfectly balanced, and it’s clear they take pride in their craft. No flop, and served in an orange slice — if you know, you know. This place is a hidden gem; I’ve tried many spots in the Atlanta area, and nothing comes close. I hope this business thrives for years to come — pizza lovers, do not miss it!

Every single time I have guests staying at my house, I bring them here. They are all absolutely blown away at the taste (and size) of the pizza. Their salads are cold and crisp. I have never had a bad meal here. The crust of the pizza is thin, not soggy, and a bit buttery. Each pie or slice has the exact right amount of delicious sauce and toppings. I have been eating here for years and it never gets old.

My family has been a customer for at least 15 years and always order the same thing for birthdays. Today is my brothers birthday and we ordered a XL pizza and a Greek salad. The Greek salad is usually large enough for 3-4 people to share. Today they barely gave me salad. I got more toppings than lettuce. We were also given old expired dressing. And was charge full price 8.75. I called to make them aware and spoke with Josie who was very argumentative with me and continued to threaten to view cameras because she swore she opened the box of salad to show me and ask if it was ok before I left. There was no way she could have because the bag with the box of salad was in my hand when she opened the pizza box to confirm it was good. I explained multiple times that she did not open the box of sal

Was lucky enough to get a big pie for work. I was surprised by how huge the big pie was. Definitely exceeded my expectations. Love the new York style pie. It was nice and hot. Generous amounts of ingredients on the pizza and 1-2 slices for me were more than enough to fill my stomach up. Super greasy but that's because of the amount of cheese and pepperoni on it. The grease adds to the flavor and experience. Overall a satisfactory experience. Prices are a bit high but the pies they serve justify it.