Blue Moon Pizza

Great spot for take-out Italian, including us tourists who have kitchenettes in our hotel rooms. Dining options in Cape May have become quite expensive and time-consuming (not to mention the challenges of parking). Food was better than we expected - loved the chicken wings so much we got them again on night two. Very friendly staff and prompt turn-around on our phone order. I have included pics of their menu as of 1/1/2026, so cross check pricing against the services like Slice, as you should for every pizza joint.

The food here is good, the pasta and meatballs is very good. It smells a little weird at first but it tastes nothing like it smells, it’s very good. Not a fan of the salad, needs less cucumber more lettuce. Looks like they don’t have tiramisu here.

Had a great time dining here. Perfect atmosphere for family and friends to gather for a casual weekend out. Food was amazing, and the service was excellent. Waiters/waitresses are friendly and very fast. Will be back again soon.

Great little spot right across from the beach. Reasonable priced for prime location with actually really good pizza! Their by the slice selection was well rounded and should please any palette desiring a slice. The crust was soft, cheese melted and stretchy, and sauce with a robust tomato taste. Each slice we ordered were both consistently cooked and great taste. The staff were welcoming and helpful. Definitely would recommend grabbing a few slices if you're looking for a quick bite or needing to feed the family.

No idea how long the new owners think they are gonna last but I'd bet not very long. Definitely the worst pizza in Cape May. I'm not even sure whats going on in this place, I asked for one of the day old slices in there display case and he took it in the back of the place in a back room and brought it back out 5min later?? I gues he was back there putting it in the microwave.. never again.