Boardwalk Pizza

I stumbled into Boardwalk Pizza completely by accident while returning something to the The UPS Store nearby—so first off, kudos on the location. From the outside and inside, it looks exactly like what you’d expect from a classic New York–style pizzeria: casual, slice-ready, dine-in or grab-and-go. Being from New York myself, I admit I’m a bit of a pizza snob. I have standards. I grabbed a simple slice just to test the waters: cheese and ricotta, no red sauce. For me, the real test is always the dough. If the dough is right, the rest usually follows. I was pleasantly surprised. The crust was super thin—true New York thin—and honestly delicious. Light, properly proofed, flavorful, and most importantly, not swampy, which is something Florida pizza unfortunately struggles with sometimes.

Such a fun small town feel. I take my son here often and he loves the gluten free pizza. The staff are amazing and the openish kitchen design is reminiscent of a NYC pizzeria.

Been a customer for 15 years and I’ve watched it steadily go downhill over the last 5. I’m done now. Just got a Stromboli that had almost no meat. 2 tablespoons of sausage and a few slices of pepperoni, 85% dough. The previous time got a meatball sub, not even enough meatballs to fill the roll. This is really sad. At this point just close up and find a better way to make money.

Our students at camp were fueled this week by the delicious pasta on Tuesdays and fresh pizza on Fridays from Osceola Boardwalk Pizza. The meals weren't just tasty but they also brought smiles, energy, and a sense of community to every table. Thank you for being part of our students amazing journey at GEMS Camp. Your support means more than just a meal!🎊

Well, me and my husband were pretty disappointed, the pizza just didn’t have much sauce at all so it was really really dry. Maybe it’s a bad day but this was our first time trying Boardwalk. And we didn’t realize they were large pizzas but that was on us lol I got a double dough pizza with meatball, chicken, bacon and sausage and my husband got a deluxe pizza with a lot of toppings lol We might try this place again and ask for extra sauce? 😅