Brewster Restaurant

Great atmosphere and staff! It's so clean and esthetically appealing inside! We got a mix of breakfast and lunch on a Saturday afternoon and everything was pretty good! The home fries could be cooked more, less butter on the toast, but everything else was great! Finally a place that doesn't burn your omlet!

We had dinner there a few times this year. The atmosphere very nice and service friendly. However I found the quality of the food prep to be not consistent . For example an order of fish and chips. When served there was a bed of small burnt chips and the fish greasy presented on top to cover chips. Now there was three orders and they all varied . Other times we had dinner there everything was perfect. I will give them another chance to win me over.

I ordered takeout, a chicken quesadilla and a steak quesadilla and both were terrible. They were fried in oil and were a greasy mess. Quesadillas should have a crispy toasted exterior not greasy. The steak quesadilla was made with ground beef not steak. We tried to eat them, but they were terrible. I returned them and the “new owners” refused to refund my money. So much for the customer is always right. I won’t ever order from Brewster Restaurant again. And I thought styrofoam containers was banned in NJ.

First visit was a hot turkey platter. It was OK, although I did not care for the yellow thick disgusting gravy on top. I guess that’s a personal thing. This visit I ordered off their website the flounder stuffed with crab meat listed as $18.99. When I arrived, I was told it was $27.99. I told the cashier as well as showing her the webpage. Legally, they are supposed to honor the price. They did not so I left without the meal. Not going back and not recommending that place.

The staff are friendly, the food was delicious, and the portions were generous. A good value for the money. One of the very few times I actually got my potatoes crispy when I asked for them that way! Also the Coffee was really good too. Nothing Fancy but the place was Clean and Comfortable.