Brothers Delicatessen

Best subs on Long Island. When you go, try to make sure one of the guys takes your orders. Had a lady there once that gave me the saddest sandwich ever, so I always make sure one of the guys takes my order. you get more than what you pay for! Sandwiches are stuffed.

Brother’s Deli is an iconic local spot serving up some of the best sandwiches you’ll find on the island. The food is consistently fresh, hearty, and exactly what you want from a true deli. If you’re putting in a big order, it’s smart to call ahead assuming the phone line isn’t disconnected that day. There’s seating inside if you want to sit down, but this place really shines for people on the go. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or stocking up before heading out on the water, Brother’s Deli is a must-stop for anyone going boating.

I was looking for a good deli and my coworker recommended us this place. I been here numerous times, however whenever we come here, the service is very slow, and the staff seem untrained and not attentive. The owner has poor customer service skills with an attitude. I experienced him tell a customer that complain about his sandwich, not to come back. The sandwiches are good, however I would never go back to this place after an experience like this!

They turn off the grill at 12 o’clock so you cant get breakfast sandwiches or any hot food because the time of the day matters so much to them they won’t cook eggs if its 1pm. Awful! This deli would make way more money if that goes away.

Been going to this deli for 20 years all of a sudden a new rule no breakfast sandwiches including eggs after 12. No where in their business is there a sign stating this. They just made it up recently and don’t even notice or care they’re losing money and life-long customers. Ridiculously shameful and stupid.