Butter Smashburgers

Rating: 9/10 Date Visited: 1/16/2026 I ordered the House Smashburger Double ($11). I came here as part of a smashburger crawl and this was the best burger I had. The meat is cooked very well and goes great with the cheese, sauce, and additional toppings. The bun was toasted and buttered just enough to not take away from the burger itself but instead add to it. The price is pretty standard and a bit cheaper than some of the other places. Overall, I would recommend this place if you want a really good smashburger.

Really loved the fries and dessert here, the cheeseburger was really good lots of flavor. Fig burger of month was okay a bit sweet for my taste, not a personal favorite but ill be back for a regular burger!

I got a double and was pleasantly surprised, it is a bit bigger than other smash burgers in the area. The fries are the best of any other smash burger shops in the area. I’ll go back for just the fries.

Butter Smashburgers is an essential stop for any burger lover in New York. The patties were smashed to perfection, juicy but not dripping, sandwiched in a light brioche bun. Great fries. Great value. It doesn’t get any better. A must try for any burger connoisseur.

I had the double cheeseburger combo. The burger was only okay, the patty was overcooked. The fries were good.