Captain's Pizza Shelton

The people here truly care about their guests. It's a cozy, hometown spot—not fancy, but warm and welcoming. The staff, especially at the bar, are friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home. The owner is committed to providing excellent service and ensuring everyone leaves satisfied. They offer a wide variety of delicious food, consistently good in quality. Overall, it's a place that feels like a second home, where good food and genuine care go hand in hand.

Customer service at its best and the pizza is great take out is what I usually get but if you wanna stay in and eat they have many tables and great servers 😊

I have been a long time customer and now a disappointed customer. I had a salad delivered that had very little toppings with a heap of lettuce. The Captains salad. I called to express my concern that the salad was cheaply done. Surprisingly, the woman was rude and debated with me about the salad rather than simply apologize and offer a refund or a new one. She had me send a picture of the salad. I called back, she still debated about it. Like I said, I’ve been a long time customer and this is my first disappointment, and it was handled poorly. No resolve. No refund and not a new salad. They just lost a customer I had a work meeting scheduled there this coming week with clients, I will be canceling this event. Shocking how I was treated as a long time customer over a $15 salad.

Excellent Food been going to Captains for years at some of their various locations throughout Fairfield county. Stopped at this location last night and was not let down. The food was great. their Greek Gyros 🥙 are some of the best I’ve ever had and I’ve been to a lot Greek festivals and diners and none compare nice long thick shards of lamb pita 🥙 very packed and filling . The steak fries were right on the money💰 .Restaurant has great atmosphere as well would suggest anyone looking for Greek food when in the area to stop here. Their pizza 🍕 is really good too 👍

Terrible experience for the last time ! When ever I have delivered we over tip by far... Charged extra for feta that did not arrive with our order. Shrimp piccata tasted like olive oil and shrimp. When I called i was told that they made a mistake on the feta and the Piccatta with zero compensation