Caraglio's Pizza

Love seeing bad reviews and then going into the public profile to see what miserable humans they are and only leave 5 stars to places who give special treatment. Yeah frank im talking about you... anyways. 5 stars for the Hilton location. I ordered for superbowl Sunday on the website and there was either a glitch with my bank or glitch with the system. It wouldn't accept my order but put a hold for the charge. I called, spoke with Jessica and she made sure one way or another I was getting my order when I wanted it regardless of the money situation. About an hour later, the hold was released and I called back to pay for my order. My wife and I use to run a very busy pizza shop and know what it takes to do this job. Can't please EVERYONE, yes Frank, about you again. I am very pleased with th

Was so upset when I got home. Should have opened the box before I left. Never seen a cheese pizza so burnt in my life. 7-11 has better. Sry

We ordered from the Webster location. The cheese pizza was burnt, crust was thin and very dry. Absolutely disgusting!

Best one in the chain is this location. They make great pizzas, simple and elaborate. Out of the dozen places to order pizza within 5 miles. You'll never find a better locally made pizza done right!

Really good pizza, probably the best dough around. Constantly cooked perfectly. Great amount of toppings. They consistently make the pizzas smaller than advertised, and that isn't just this location. The one pictured is a large, which is supposed to be 16 inches, but closer to 15 1/4. I know that sounds picky, but that adds up to be a large area, especially when it happens every time. I'll still be back, but know what you're getting. The size discrepancy is worse on sheets.