Carmine's Pizza Kitchen-Gibson

Disclaimer: I rate based solely on my own experience. If the owner or staff feel this review doesn’t reflect their best work, I’m always open to a conversation and a call back to make it right. Carmine’s brings that old-school Italian charm the second you sit down. Red-checkered tables, warm lighting, and the kind of kitchen smells that let you know you’re in the right place. The spaghetti and meatballs were exactly what I hoped for – big, hearty meatballs, plenty of sauce, and that nostalgic “family dinner” flavor. Comfort food executed well. The garlic knots were soft, warm, and covered with just the right amount of parmesan, paired with a marinara that tastes homemade. Solid starter. The pizza was a standout: crisp crust, fresh toppings, and great balance. You can tell they actually

The wife and I like new pizza experiences, but when we found out that the owner of Carmine's is the former owner of Villa Pizza we expected a lot from the pizza at Carmine's. We were not disappointed, the pizza was great and the cannolis are tasty too. We also got an order of chicken parm to go, which we had the next day for lunch and it was tasty as well. All the locations are far from us, but for great pizza we are willing to make the drive. Enjoy everyone!

We came here on New Year’s Eve with our family of 9. The staff were incredibly friendly. Super attentive with a smile!! Everyone loved their pizzas. Thin and crispy crust with good flavors. We really enjoyed it. Noah was an amazing server!

It is a smaller restaurant so seating is limited, but the food is absolutely delicious. Their Italian flag pizza and their garlic knots were so good but the star of my show was the spinach roll. So packed with spinach and garlic and cheese. Just spectacular.

Absolutely wonderful experience! It is perfect place for dealerships and businesses around the Area . Family owned and operated since 1976, Carmine's Pizza Kitchen is the perfect selection for some old school NY pizza and Italian food. Our server was so friendly and helpful. He is definitely a huge asset to the restaurant. Everyone is very welcoming and treat you like a family . A great place to dine in or get takeout. The food was outstanding, and the portions are pretty large. - The calzone was very tasty, the cheese was melted perfectly and it was baked to perfection. - The garlic knots were super delicious and the size was great too ,they were not too oily, just perfect balance of flavors. - For the dessert we had cannolis, they were delicious, the shell had perfect crunch, not too