Carnegie Diner & Cafe

Everything was a 10/10! We truly enjoyed our experience from start to finish. Everyone was very welcoming too. The food was amazing, and we were especially grateful to Elena, who patiently helped us decide what to order. Surprisingly, we loved everything she suggested, especially the steak it was delicious! We’ll definitely be coming back. Thank you for such a wonderful experience.

Highly recommend this place if you want a taste of the American cuisine. The food was fresh. The service perfect. The interior welcoming. Give it a try yourself.

Excellent service ( shout-out to Colombian tattoo artist waiter! ) and delicious authentic Greek salad, perfectly made almond coffee latte. Comfortable affordable mellow spot in an otherrwise busy chaotic neighborhood. Clean . Large menu. Many folks ordering burgers there, and pre theatre special which is all the time is fair deal. Went 2x and will definitely return. Keep up this quality!

Everything was fantastic. Great flavors, huge portions, and fresh fruit. And as usual for NYC, my only critic is season the hash browns more. That seems to be a running theme for all hash browns in the city. This southern boy needs some pop. Outside of that, I’d be back to try more items. The menu is huge!

I had such a great experience at this restaurant! I ordered the Banana Nutella Strawberries Pancake stack, which came with three fluffy pancakes layered perfectly. The portions were generous, and the presentation looked just as good as it tasted. My server, Andriana, was very kind, attentive, and welcoming.