Caruso's Pizzeria

Amazing pizza and delicious food! The owner and her staff are incredibly friendly and make the experience even better. During the snowstorm, I stocked up on several dishes and everything was excellent. The sauce is outstanding. Highly recommend to anyone in the area!

Out of town and googled the best pizza. WOW! They weren’t lying. The crust is amazing, not too cheesy and the sauce just right. Service 5 star ⭐️ The chicken Caesar salad slice was in a class by itself! Cheers to our next adventure 🥂

Active Duty Navy. Stopped in for a quick slice with my family after 5 weeks training away from family. The pizza was SOOO GOOD! But what was even better was the service! The manager was so generous and kind! She really took care of us! Highly recommend! If you get a chance stop by you won’t regret it. 🍕😭👍🤩

Caruso's was exceptional! During my five day stay out in Islip, I dined there twice. The staff was like a family, and they treated mine like we were part of theirs. I tried the Sicilian pie with eggplant, and it was easily the best pizza I've tasted in a long time. It was delicious! On my second trip, we all opted for different plates of pasta, which were also excellent. Afterward, we couldn't resist taking a chicken Ceasars pie back to the hotel for a try later on. Another crazy delicious combo! Im definitely hitting Caruso's when Im back in New York.

We ordered and received Delicious white and margarita pizza. One of the best. There are several good pizza places in Riverhead but I enjoy this place very much. Nice dining area in rear. Very friendly staff.