Casey's

Never had issues with CEFCO here before, now that they are Casey’s it seems customers need to supply their own paper products in the men’s room. When I asked if that were the case, the reply was “Mmm, I’m not sure but I can check.” The pizza was good and people friendly but make sure you bring back-up paper products inside with you. Edit: in their response they didn’t even bother to apologize for the issues. When people adult-up and acknowledge they messed up, it is real easy to forgive and put it behind. When they snowflake like this, I have a hard time ever going back.

A gas station isn’t supposed to have pizza this delicious

For the most part the store is clean & the employees are very friendly, it was nice to see so many of the old Cefco employees kept their jobs, but the food is nowhere near it's old quality. The pizza crust and mozzarella was so rubbery two slices made my jaw sore and I nearly choked another time because the dough was overworked and the cheese is cheaply made. There was almost no flavor in the pepperoni, cheese or sauce (what little of it there was) at all. I was pretty disappointed because everyone keeps raving about this amazing gas station pizza. But for me, I'll eat if it's all I've got but regret it later, if I'm still alive. Thank goodness the employees are still awesome! Casey's might have crummy pizza but they have a great staff.