Castiglia's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Very much enjoyed our dinner. The gluten free pizza was legit. They have amazing red sauce and use quality ingredients. My wife had the white pie and it was good as well. The menu had tons of other gluten free options. The service was superb. The inside was a little dated but I’m not going for the looks.

Our first time here. Passed it a few times and decided to give it a try. Food was good. A few items were bland. Appetizers and dessert were delicious. I'd definitely give it another try. The waitress was amazing. Very helpful and very polite. 😁👍🏼

We decided to go try dessert and the Bacio puffs did not disappoint! They are delicious! The hostesss was also very friendly and helpful answering my questions about what to try!

I tried this place for the first time last night and had a mixed experience. I ordered two pepperoni pizzas — one original and one with spinach and green peppers — and both were really good. No complaints there. I also ordered a Margherita pizza, and unfortunately it was the complete opposite. I’m not sure what went wrong, but it had absolutely no flavor and was basically inedible. I can usually push through anything, but this one was rough. For the price, it was really disappointing. I didn’t see any reviews calling out the Margherita specifically, so maybe this was just an off night, but something was definitely missing. If you enjoy real, authentic Margherita pizza, this isn’t the place for that. The mark was definitely missed. I do hope they improve it, because the other pizzas were

Was excited to try this place out since it is near my house. Ordered Chicken & Shrimp Napoli and mozzarella sticks for pickup. Came to a total of $37 with no itemized receipt provided. Opened and was disappointed to discover there was no breaded chicken and only a few pieces of shrimp. Sauce itself was good, but for what I got nowhere near worth the price.