Catusco's Pizza

The best pizza in Huntington and Beyond. James is a good guy & knows what he’s doing. The crust is amazing… no flops, it stands straight up nice and crisp. There are Old school vibes here, I love that he has the real deal pepperoni cups (hard to find) upside down pie is a winner, hot honey pepperoni squares. The hero’s and food entrees is a must try as well. A+++++++++

So this is one of the last remaining family pizzerias on this very planet. I wish for this place to ascend into the heavens and maintain their quality and orginality while achieving maximum flight. I was just catered to with a custom made order, a friendly experience, and me knowing this place is legit. Real deal steel here

Truly some of the best pizza I've ever had, in Long Island or the world, and I've lived in Italy before. James Catusco has his recipes locked in well, packing incredible flavor into a menu of pizza, calzones, heroes, stromboli, knots, salads and more. Even with flavor combinations like Sausage and peppers, Vodka Meatball, White Artichoke, or even hot honey pepperoni, you'll never run out of menu items to try even if you are a local. Seriously, try their pizza, you won't regret it. It really doesn't get much better than Catusco's.

I usually come here with my daughter after I pick her up from school. I’m glad I have a local pizza place that places emphasis on customer satisfaction. They have amazing pizza. I catered for my son’s birthday party and they did an amazing job, I can’t thank them enough!

One of the best slices of pizza on Long Island! In less than a week, I returned with a friend to eat here for lunch. We started with slices, (2) Hot Honey Vodka Square with Pepperoni, and we split (1) Chicago-style with Pepperoni and Sausage. While we ate those, we patiently waited for our kitchen orders. Shrimp Parmigiana Hero with Vodka sauce and an order of (8) parm garlic wings. The hero was fantastic. Bread was crisp, and that vodka sauce is super flavorful. The wings came out super hot, and they were really flavorful. It was like, Garlic Knot wings, tbh, so it was surprisingly delicious alone, without any ranch/blue cheese. As if we didn't order enough, the owner graciously surprised us with a complimentary stromboli. A+ customer service, prices are more than reasonable, and the fo