Celestino's New York Pizza

Best place for pizza in town. If you like the thin foldable greasy pizza. Thicker crusts I prefer woodstocks. But love the lunch slice deals too. It’s my go to place. The location hasn’t changed much in at least 20 years and I like that nostalgic feel also.

I was going treasure hunting with my partner. We hadn't had lunch yet, so Start the Countdowns band leader suggested Celestinos. It was pizza I love and couldn't get for a long time. I showed Matt a place to look and he found melted metal and a couple of small 14k gold crosses. Nothing compared to the diamonds, pearl, rubys and sapphires that I'd found in that spot. I tried to find the owner but know luck.

Hands down BEST pizza in town!! Thin slice, perfect crisp crunch and the toppings are phenomenally fresh! 🤗 My personal favorite is the Tom Jones, Soo delicious! Definitely a "MUST TRY!"I could eat here the rest of my days! Thank you to the staff for the service 💯 I appreciate you making a fresh pizza when there were no more Tom Jones Slices left and being so kind to me! I'll see you again soon!!

Killer pizza and beer deals, solid large slices ~ however. The vents and air filters are clearly caked in dust and debris right above where you eat and serve food. I count 5 employees here on a Thursday afternoon, it takes one employee 5 minutes twice a year to clean and change these filters. Do better...

Came in for a quick bite of lunch and was not disappointed! Chose the slide and salad combo with the Caesar salad option. Pizza was flavorful, I really like that the crust was thinner, but still nice and fluffy. They seem to mix some sort of flavoring into the cheese, which made my slice of pepperoni extra tasty. This is definitely a traditional college pizzeria, but still a good place to stop in! Overall a nice a filling lunch for under $13. Staff was super nice and patient as I took in the different food and pizza options. I would definitely come back again, and would recommend for a economical and satisfying lunch!