Cittanuova

Many times you read reviews and say not sure. But my wife and I were very happy with our entire night. Our server Danny was absolutely amazing. We asked about the differences between a few entrees and his description was spot on. Was also checking in on us and never had to wait for anything except the check since he wanted us to enjoy our time out. Would go back again.

Perfect place to do to for date night. We enjoyed our meal. Service was good, but it took a while for the food to get to us. We had the chicken Parmesan, pasta with oyster mushroom and Brussel sprouts on the side. The desserts were pretty good too. Our waitress made sure we were taken care of. We got a nice cozy spot for ourselves. We’d Recommend this spot if you’re looking for a place to eat in EH.

Dinner mid-May, slightly off season but one of the better options in EH. All our dishes were delicious and well made. The calamari and zucchini appetizer was lightly fried, fresh and tasty. The eggplant Parmesan was very good. The minestrone was a little disappointing personally, a little thick, almost like tomato sauce, and the flavor was a bit sharp, perhaps too acidic. Not cheap but for the Hamptons not too crazy either. Lovely service.

We went to Citta for the soup on a night of 8° outside. It is a very short ride and Sam's was not open. It was awful. The onion soup was 1 notchabove inedible. My wife returned hers for Minestrone which may have been a notch better. My lasagna was very disappointing and the Margaretta Pizza was also disappointing. We will not go back.

We went to Cittanouva for a takeaway pizza and ordered around five pizzas. Unfortunately, the experience was really disappointing. When we arrived to collect our order, one of the pizzas was missing, and we were told it would be another five minutes — while the rest of our pizzas sat there getting cold. The two girls at reception were extremely rude and impolite throughout. There was no apology for the delay, just attitude, which made the whole experience quite unpleasant. To make matters worse, the pizza itself wasn’t great, and by the time we got home, everything was cold. We won’t be returning — mainly because of the poor service, but sadly the food didn’t make up for it either.