Coleman Brook Tavern

We decided to give this place a try and boy oh boy, did we score!? We did not reserve a table, and it was crowded when we arrived. Magical Madison made the difference for us, she had us seated in a prime spot in half an hour. She was personable, warm and completely efficient. She runs the desk with such grace and ease. I hope she is being paid well. Our server, Kaiya, was amazing! She knew about the foods and the specials and she made great suggestions as well. Her service was excellent! We had the pork osso buco — delish! The burger, which was done to my specifications and delivered quickly, grilled pork with green beans, grilled pork medallions- so tender and seasoned right! The ceasar salad was crisp and fresh, our appetizers were all phenomenal from the chicken wings to the dumplings

Food was good, they treated us well, and the drinks were strong enough to keep us happily distracted while the kitchen was fighting for its life. We first visited on New Year’s Day for dinner, which is apparently the restaurant equivalent of running a marathon while juggling knives. The kitchen was getting absolutely crushed, so they stopped accepting walk-ins. We pivoted to the bar which was the best decision. Full restaurant service, front-row entertainment, and bartenders who were on their A-game despite the chaos. Shoutout to Nico, Michael, and a third gentleman whose name we sadly missed—all hilarious, attentive, and impressively unfazed. Watching them keep things moving while cracking jokes felt like dinner and a show. We returned the next night and learned the staff was short-hande

Came here for New Year’s Day dinner. 4 adults, 5 children. Our reservation was at 6:45, we were seated at 7. It took about 15 minutes for a server to arrive, another 20 for the drinks to arrive. After an hour and a half with no sign of food, we spoke with the front desk. The manager, who we previously witnessed berating a young man bussing tables, came over to tell us they were short staffed for a litany of reasons. This should have been relayed to all patrons at the door. As we spoke to her about chicken fingers and mac and cheese for our children not taking much time, she walked away. We then saw a table who arrived 45 minutes after us receive their food. Ours arrived at the two hour mark. Whenever we have experienced such sub par service, something is typically taken off the bill as a c

i dont know what the other reviews were talking about. we got some of the fastest service ive ever had at a sit down restaurant. the food was great too. highly recommend

We came here for our anniversary and enjoyed an amazing dinner and bottle of wine for their Monday special Italian night. Callie was the nicest server and provided 5 star service. Thank you so much for a wonderful experience 🥰🥰