Colts Neck Eatery

Very bright, clean, friendly atmosphere. Host and server were both very nice - friendly and attentive. Had genuine conversations with the customers. Breakfast food was very good. I appreciate that they will substitute potatoes and toast for pancakes. We got ham & American cheese omlette and "Yaya" or western omlette with pancakes. I added a side of toast. Omlette filling was a very generous amount. No wait to get in. Would come back.

This is RARE for me...5 STARS! Everything about this Eatery was top notch, fairly priced, service was on point, friendly, and very attentive without the "smothering". Most of all the food was delicious, the presentation of my omelet was like eating at a 5 star resort. I have no complaints. The restaurant was clean, and the decor gave rustic farmhouse chic.

We had Sunday brunch here! The atmosphere was great, the people were nice, the food tasted good. Loved the selection on the menu. We noticed that the servers were really quick with their interactions, I suppose to keep turning tables around but it felt rushed. My husband’s coffee mug had lipstick on it so I’m not even sure that the dishes were properly cleaned. The server also sat the coffee mug directly in front of our toddler and he immediately puts his hands in the mug. No safety awareness due to the servers rushing everything. Luckily the coffee wasn’t lava hot.

As mediocre as it gets when it comes to breakfast places. We got the Florentine Bemedict with breakfast potatoes, which wasn't terrible, to be honest (3.5/10). The "hungry man platter" was a completely different story. Eggs were hard, and the cheese I asked for scrambled in the eggs was just sprinkled on top and not even fully melted. The bacon was hard, and sausage + kielbasa were tough and rubbery. The pancakes were pretty bad as well. Now, when I ordered a mac n cheese with bacon from the apps portion of the menu, I'm not sure what I expected, but it certainly was NOT Kraft with some hard bacon just dropped on top of it. I was genuinely shocked when our server brought that out. Speaking of servers, our waitress was and whom i am assuming is the owner were both really nice , no complain

Our first time here and we were definitely impressed by the decor and service by Matty. She made sure we had a great brunch. See photos of what we enjoyed. Definitely will be back and look forward to enjoying more on the menu. I hear the wraps are really good here.