Cone Crazy Ice Cream Shop

This place is amazing. I got ice cream from there twice. The staff are nice and friendly. She told me what ice cream has on it. She explained very well. They have different varieties of ice cream and etc. They also give samples of ice cream you want to try before buying it. They have outside display of different cups and cones for ice cream.They don't have special of the day ice cream. Do bring cash if can. They do charge 2% extra when paying credit card or debit card. You order from the outside and you get your order from another window. There is a place to sit and eat what you have ordered.

Highly recommend Cone Crazy for customized ice cream cakes! I needed a Beach themed cake for my cousin’s 50th birthday and they were so easy to work with. The owner Steve provided his cell# for easier communication which I really appreciated. Not only was the ice cream cake absolutely delicious, they did an amazing job with the design. My cousin was so thrilled to have a beach themed cake with her favorite ice cream flavors for her milestone birthday! If you are local to the area or visiting Wildwood ( like us) do not miss out and try their ice cream. It’s amazing!! Thank you so much Steve and staff!!! The cake was a HUGE Hit!!

Update: in 2025 we were still grateful to have a vegan option (vanilla) and the flavor and toppings were still great, but they must have changed their supplier since the texture was kind of odd (chewy and marshmallow instead of creamy). Really tasty vegan (non-dairy) ice cream! They only have one flavor (vanilla) but it had a great creamy texture. They have several toppings that are vegan although only sprinkles can go on top of a cone (as opposed to a cup). The attached picture is of a "small" (two huge scoops).

Only a 5-minute walk from our hotel room, we headed to the ice cream shop for some after-dinner dessert. It's a nice little place right by the beach and only a few minutes from the Boardwalk. With lots of great flavors to choose from, we ordered the Barking Pretzel, Monster Cookie with rainbow sprinkles, Strawberry with gummy worms, and After-Dinner Mint shake. We'll definitely come back again to try the other flavors. The gentleman who took our order was very friendly and helpful, as well as the girl who prepared our order.

Easily walkable from our condo. Just south of the boardwalk. Great flavors to choose from! I was thinking about the peanut butter and pretzel flavor for hours afterward! Small seating area outside, otherwise it's to-go. The only negative was a fluctuation in wait time. First visit, we were in a decent line, but things moved quickly. Second visit, we had to bow out of a similar line because things were moving so slowly.