Corleone's Old Fashion Tomato Pie & Pizza

After eating. Excellent n recommend. Wing was dry . Skinny . But good

Visited 8/19/2025. The tomato pie slice was hot and crispy, with sweet tomatoes and a strong undercarriage. The Sicilian tomato pie slice was crispy in some places and soggy in others. I think it could have used another turn in the oven. I was still hungry after the two slices so I had one more regular plain slice, which was good. Crispy, hot, and everything you want in a slice of Jersey-style pizza. #YouWannaPizzaMe?

A fantastic version of the traditional (Trenton style) tomato pie! The sauce is very tart (not sweet, which is what I expected), with a rich tomato flavor. The cheese is a little on the greasy side, but compliments the sauce and crisp crust very well! Definitely easy to eat five or six slices! If you enjoy old school tomato pies, absolutely give Corleone's a try!! (There is dine-in, but space is extremely limited to three small tables)

Best pizza in Mercer County! I drive 20 minutes because I'm outside of their delivery zone, and it's worth it every time! Old school real deal taste, and it's always hot & fresh!

I went there for the first time after 10 years today and I gotta say it was even better than it used to be. The pizza was fresh and crispy. The sauce was outstanding. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. One the of the best slices of pizza in Hamilton hands down.