Cosmo's Pizzeria Southern Shores at the Market Place

I tried the pepperoni and sausage pizza. The dough is fresh. The sauce has a nice kick to it. The mozzarella sticks taste like they are made fresh. They aren’t the usual generic frozen ones. Definitely worth a try as well.

Best pizza in the northern outer banks. Cosmo’s is a great pizza place with two locations, one in southern shores that is open year around, and a great location in Corolla light open during the season. Pizza is great and a family favorite. We never pass up the chance to go to Cosmo’s when we are here. Have also had the calzone, meatball grinder and chicken parm. Would recommend them all. Loved the calzone with pepperoni.

We were in the Kitty Hawk area celebrating Thanksgiving. There's only so much turkey you can eat, so Saturday night we decided to get a pizza and take it back to the Air B&B where we were staying (great place BTW) and settle in with a good movie Cosmo's pizza was OUTSTANDING!!! The service was great and the pizza was hot and ready exactly when they said it would be. Great experience. Highly recommend it.

Best pizza on the Outer Banks! Forget Slice and all the others, pass them by and come here! The serving sizes are incredible! Ask for a box, you’ll need it. The sandwiches were huge, the pizza was delicious, and the calzones were unreal! Plus you get to watch the guys in the back hand toss the dough!

Yo! Let's talk about Cosmo's Pizzeria, a pizza spot that’s absolutely worth checking out! This place serves up some seriously delicious pizza, and I’m here to tell you why it’s a must-visit. The star of the show is their regular cheese slice—it’s pure perfection. The crust strikes that ideal balance of crispy edges and soft, chewy center, giving every bite a great texture. The sauce is vibrant, with just the right mix of tangy and slightly sweet that makes it super addictive. And the cheese? It’s melty, stretchy, and generously layered, creating that classic pizza magic that keeps you coming back for more. Honestly, one bite of this slice and you’ll be hooked—it’s that good. Cosmo’s has a laid-back vibe, friendly staff, and portions that don’t skimp. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice o