Covello's Pizza

Visited 9/22/25. Slices came out fresh and hot from the oven as we entered the restaurant. I had a plain slice and a sausage slice. The sauce was sweet but not overly so, thick and gooey cheese. Crispy undercarriage, chewy crust. The sausage crumbles were substantial! #YouWannaPizzaMe?

Typically service is faster than what today’s was with 5 people there but this fish and chips combo has to go. This can’t be fish, flattened as a damn chicken cutlet.

Great pizza — fresh, flavorful, and definitely one of the better slices I’ve had. The food itself did not disappoint. That said, the experience was confusing. There were no menus posted in the store — just a TV displaying the date and time. I found one takeout menu sitting on the counter, which listed gourmet slices at $4 each. When I ordered two slices, I was charged $9. When I asked about the difference, I was told the takeout menu was “expired” and was shown a coupon on it that expires 12/31/25. That appears to be the expiration date for the coupon, not the menu pricing. Also, we’re already in the middle of February and there is still no updated menu available. They should either honor the old pricing until a new menu is clearly provided or make the updated pricing visible. Clear, poste

Price is always changing!! I’ve been coming for like 2 years now. I gave it several chances because I'm close by. I’m over it though be mindful!! The menu prices did go up 2/3 dollars

I called to pick up a salad and went to pick up about 20 minutes later. Upon arriving, the staff took about 4 people before getting to me, despite me standing at the counter and waiting. I completely understand there was a lunch rush, but I continuously said, “Excuse me” to staff before them going to the next person. Additionally, when I was able to finally let someone know I had called ahead, another customer (not the restaurants fault) proceeded to cut me off and tell me to wait until she was finished, to which staff continued on with her. I had been in the restaurant for about 10 minutes before leaving after that exchange. For there to be 5-6 people behind the counter and people not adequately taking orders doesn’t make much sense to me. I left without my order today and will not be o