DOUGH by Licastri Eltingville

We’ve been ordering pizza from this location since they opened a location closer to us. We are moving and decided our last pizza was going to from Dough. They left us a beautiful message on our box and surprised us with zeppoles. Definitely ate one of those first since they taste best when they are fresh. Thank you everyone at DOUGH! This meal will power us through our move and thanks for the delicious dough over the years

Dough is amazing.. not only for the Pizza but for the great food and service. Never a bad meal. The eggplant parmigiana comes with a side of pasta. The best eggplant parmigiana next to my mothers. Freddy is great, and his daughters are the best. The service from everyone is outstanding.

This shop has such a warm, homey feel and you can tell they truly care about every customer who walks in. It brings back that old-school pizza shop experience from 20 years ago, but with a clean, modern aesthetic and a fresh, new-school energy. The owner is incredibly hospitable and the staff all take pride in the shop and the service they provide. Thank you for a great meal and an even better experience — I’ll definitely be back.

It’s a shame when you live 1.5 miles from someplace and your food comes so cold that my chicken Marsala dinner the oil was separated from the sauce. The pizza, fried calamari and rice balls were ice cold. Everything had to be reheated in the oven but my salad was perfect temp to eat. It took an hour for delivery so it must have been in his car for 45 minutes. Haven’t order from them in over 6 months so I tried them again and no luck. It’s a real shame that there is really no good places left to eat in Staten Island anymore. We always go to Brooklyn or New Jersey to eat out.

Dough by Licastri (eltingville) Not even sure where to start. Delivery was fast and food was fresh and hot. We had a little big of everything 😅, the fried calamari was hot and crispy, i usually hate ordering this dish bc its soggy but i will def order this from here again! The Lemon Aioli Sauce was out of this world ! I even used it on the garlic knots. The garlic knots were are a large portion and flavorful. We also had a chicken parm hero, sausage and pepper roll and chicken roll. All 3 you can tell were fresh, hot and stuffed with flavor. The scarpacci sandwhich on focchia bread tasted just like my Nonnas :) The Crisera pie was light, fresh and out of this world . I would highly recommend this place to others! Wil be ordering again from here shortly :) Update so good we ordered again