East of Chicago Pizza Mayflower

Quality has gone seriously downhill. They screwed up my pizza, then took another and threw the cheddar cheese on it that would have been on my correct pizza and pawned that nonsense off on me. Uncooked cheese on an already baked pizza…okay. I used to order here a lot, tip well etc., won’t order here again.

Ordered our pizza from there last weekend... I had no idea. They would be willing to deliver to our house because it was clear across town, What a pleasure. It was to know that they were able to deliver to us. Kayla, the manager was awesome. One or two shout out to her!! Pizza was delicious, Always a pleasure dealing with this establishment!! 🥰

I ordered a stuffed crust pizza, got home, and the crust was doughy. I took it back, and the manager said she would fix a new one. I heard a staff member in the back sigh and ask "what's wrong with it?" I'm pretty sure they just recooked the pizza I brought back because the cheese was hard and crusty and the dough was still not done. Smh. I really liked this place but looks like I gotta cut them off....... they responded that I didn't know the difference between dough not being done and stuffed crust pizza ..... ooooo kkkkkkk

I haven't had East of Chicago pizza in 15 yrs. I was in FloriDUH 4 a bit of time. I think the man whom I ordered from was the owner. Really Nice Man. I love the Taco Pizza & it was Superb !! Picture perfect also !! Made w Love !! Tasted great !!

Best Meatball Sub ever! For 10$ ! It was big enough to feed three people and had been made by a woman that was devoted to her craft. And it showed by the quality of her work. Excellent pizza also, hand made with an old world style that left me wanting more.