Empire Slice Shop - Mayfair Village

They burnt my pizza :/ Empire has a great reputation which is why I wanted to try their GF pizza, but they really over cooked it— even burnt the crust and still served it to me— which I didn’t realize until after getting back to my brother’s house. And at that point it wasn’t really worth going back because I was having lunch with family. It was edible by not eating the crust, and the toppings were really good. But over all each bite still tasted gross because of the burnt/overdone part. Huge bummer after paying $20 for a single pizza.

It’s some of the tastiest local pizza for the OKC area. This location would get a full 5 stars if they had more comfortable chairs in their dinning area. It’s a small thing, but it has a big impact. Their pizza offerings are fun and flavorful. I love that their pizza by the slice varies by the day. Their garlic knots are a solid app, especially for a larger group.

We LOVE empire. It is a favorite for our whole family, and we had so many great memories at the Nichols Hills location. My son has grown up going there. Wish they would have kept it and gotten rid of Mayfair instead. Slices are always awesome and unique, price is great, love the teacher discount, pink sauce is good, buildings are cool, great continuity across all locations, on and on. I mentioned Empire in my review of Hall’s pizza, and there’s no competition if you’re choosing between the two. Both have great pizza, but you can actually eat at or takeout from Empire. Hall’s is impossible to get into or takeout. We’ll keep giving our money to empire!! Keep it up!

Just not very good. Large Pepperoni, garlic Knots(5) and Meatballs= $50. The pizza is very thin, virtually no sauce, crust is chewy and dry, Pepperoni razor thin. Simply Domino's level. Hideaway is far superior and would cost less . I usually do not post negative, but this was just disappointing.

We'd heard all the greatest things about this place, so we met up with friends we've not seen in awhile here. Everything right up until the food was great! Loved sitting outside (not much chance to do that in February in Oklahoma), but the garlic knots seemed microwaved and the artichoke dip was pretty tasteless. We got the RBG veggie pizza and added balsamic to it. We were highly disappointed and both only ate a slice each as we were starving, but the rest ended up in the trash this morning. The cheese was great, but the sauce was lacking, leaving my pizza basically tasting like a mouthful of raw spinach. We potatoes $45 in total and left hungry. I will say the manager did come to check on us, but we aren't ones who really complain so much