Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria

I had a great experience on Friday night. I ordered a large pizza, and although I'd eaten pizza there before, the one on Friday was exceptional. I don't know if they've changed anything, but it was delicious! It's a clean, quiet place with fast and very friendly service. The kitchen staff, a woman making the pizza and another woman who took my order, seemed happy at work. I noticed that they were always smiling, and that gives off a good vibe. I highly recommend it! 👌

Great food but the prices are not consistent with the quality. This is a common problem in Bethel so it's likely just an issue of local micro economics. The name is very accurate. Most of the best items on the menu are seriously calorie dense but as long as you know that going in, you'll leave satisfied. Not really a dine in spot but there are some tables in the side room. Don't recommend sitting there in the winter.

We have been in town for a family wedding, and as I was looking through reviews for places to try, I was intrigued by Fat Tony’s menu. We decided to have lunch there today based on reviews and we were not disappointed! My husband had the Soprano on a hard roll, and our daughter got the Fat Tony grinder. We shared some Mozz Drops and also got a Lil’ Bit O Lemon pizza… and ohhh my goodness. Yes. I would eat that pizza every week from now until my earthly exit!! The service was great- they have wonderful attitudes and are so helpful, and even gave me an extra pizza sauce to go, because I haven’t had a good East Coast pizza sauce since moving. Well done, Fat Tony’s! We hope you have many successful years!

Finally tried Fat Tony’s and safe to say I’ll definitely be coming back. Everything was perfect. From the bread, to the fresh lettuce, to the chicken being perfectly seasoned. 10/10. What a perfect sandwich!!!!

Great corner hidden gem in Bethel!!! Love the whole menu! Got the Asian orange salad Delicious!!