Fierro's Pizza

This such a wonderful pizza place to have in a town filled with insanely expensive food. Not only was it very affordable it was also extremely delicious. The crust was crispy, the cheese was great quality, my pepperoni was tender and sliced so thin which was a first for me and I loved it, and the sauce was so tasty. Also the husband and wife behind the counter were so cheery and nice. It really felt like a family and they treated everyone who walked through the door so kindly. I will definitely be coming back next time I’m in town.

We really enjoyed Fiero’s Pizza in East Hampton! The pizza was absolutely delicious — hot, fresh, and full of flavor. The crust had the perfect balance of crispiness and chew, and everything came out super fast. Great spot if you’re craving quality pizza without the wait. Highly recommend!

As soon you walk in the atmosphere is relaxing. The customer service was great; friendly, fast and proficient. It was like we knew the guy for a long time. The restaurant was clean. I ordered a Buffalo chicken slice and garlic knots. It was slightly above average in taste. I would recommend Fierro's for lunch or dinner. They are located next to stop and shop in a small shopping center. So you can run errands and grab good food to go. They get 5 stars due to great customer service, excellent location, clean establishment. I'll be back soon and hope you give them a try too.

Decent neighborhood atmosphere pizzeria. Ordered a Hawaiian slice and garlic knots. Came out of their pizza oven in a few minutes at just the perfect temp. Bathroom was clean and tidy. Garlic knots was perfect. The only thing I didn’t like was that there weren’t much pineapple on the slice, though there was a decent amount of ham and cheese. Good value for the money.

i love fierros it’s literally so good the pizza is perfect and the owners are so friendly and funny and they serve you in a minute or two if they’re not too busy and it’s perfect to sit and get a quick bite in! the pizza has a really good taste and is perfectly cheesy and if you put the shaker parm on it’s even better!!! also these reviews are insane it’s nothing like what these people are saying definitely come here if you’re in east hampton it’s the best pizza here