Five Star Pizza

We stayed in town for a few days, this is a pizza place we would order from again and again! It’s was so good, very well done and one of the best pizza sauces we’ve ever tried! If you’re coming around this area, we would highly recommend you to try these pizzas!

After getting frustrated walking around St Augustine and finding no good late night food choices, I remembered seeing an ad for Five Star pizza in the Trolley Saver coupon book. I called to place a late night deliver order, and although they didn't have the special that was advertised, the girl on the phone mentioned one they did have that suited my needs. I ordered my pizza well done and with plates and some how my order still arrived within 25 minutes!!! My pizza and garlic knots were piping hot, and my 2 liter of Dr. P was cold. Rosemary was my driver and she was super sweet!!! Don't forget to sign up for rewards program for extra savings. Until next year Five Star!!

So, I was blown away at our last delivery and driver. Delivery was to The Southerly at the Shipyard this past Wednesday 02/11/2026. What integrity and honest. I tipped and my hand writing sucks. Driver call and asked about it. He said what he thought is was and that it was more than 20% He adjusted the tip. My wife and I were deeply moved. I pray the Lord blesses this person abundantly. What an inspiring moment in time when the world seems far to crazy.

We ordered pizza from here on our first night in town and it was pretty good. Incredibly fast delivery too!

Fast, hot, tasty! Ordered online and it was delivered piping hot about 20-25 min later. Triple pepperoni was great, with 3 different types of pepperoni. Buffalo chicken has a good level of spicyness but not hot to it. Recommended