Five Star Pizza

Best pizza in Tallahassee!! The specials are always great, the extra cheese pizza is the best! They always make it so nice and cheesy! The employees are always kind and professional. They will send you amazing coupons in the mail and the cutest holiday cards. It always makes my day. 10/10 pizza The only bad thing I can say is that sometimes when we order, the pizza is cold and flat and seems like it’s been sitting out for awhile or not alot of cheese when we ordered extra cheese. But some nights we get great fresh warm pizza that makes up for the bad days (:

I ordered by phone, the delivery was reasonable and prompt. The prices weren't cheap, but the pizza was excellent and a good size for the price paid. Actually the pizza was quite large. Larger than I expected. And I'll say it again, the pizza was very good.

I have been ordering pizza from Fivestar for my staff at work for the past 3 years. The staff at Five Star has always been professional, fast and friendly. The food has always been consistent, quality and freaking Delicious! Helps us power thru busy times, to meet those deadlines.

I thanked Mr Hayden in person! But I also wanted to thank him publicly! Five star has been a fav of mines, but every now and again I will venture out to other pizza joints. Ever since Hayden has taken ownership and we’re now receiving weekly deals I only find myself frequenting Five Star!!! So keep up the good work and keep those deal coming. Thank Yah Five Star for always providing excellent service!

Best chain pizza restaurant in Tallahassee! They use real Wisconsin cheese and other high quality ingredients. The team is great and has been mostly the same for many many years, which tells you everything you need to know. The employees are courteous and respectful. I have never received the wrong order or had any issue whatsoever. If you want, great quality pizza, this is the place!