Four Brothers Pizza Inn Restaurant

Delicious food at fair prices and friendly staff. Clean bathroom and well-maintained furnishings. Plenty of parking in the paved lot out front. In February 2026, NY gubernatorial candidate Larry Sharpe lunched with supporters during a campaign stop at this location.

I frequently visit several other four brothers locations and was expecting the same food from the location in Valatie. Instead I got this mediocre salad with shredded (?!) cheese on it. This is not the famous four brothers Greek salad, sorry.

We absolutely loved everything. The greek salad and margarita pizza were amazing. I loved the nice crispy crust. The meatball grinder was delicious and the bread was so fresh! Definitely worth a stop.

We had a wonderful meal today at Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant in Great Barrington. The house red (a Cabernet) was delicious — a generous pour and great flavor. We started with the Greek Salad and French fries, which arrived just as requested. The salad was outstanding: crisp cucumbers, kalamata olives, and a perfectly balanced dressing. The medium pizza — half cheese, half pepperoni — was excellent. The crust was amazing and the cheese was especially delicious. The service was also exceptional. I can’t recall our server’s name, but she checked on us throughout the meal and made sure we had everything we needed. She packed up our leftovers for us with such care. It was truly one of our best experiences dining there! Carolyn and Bob

Large, clean restaurant with a nice staff. Been here several times over a number of years and it's always the same. The pizza is really good. I haven't tried anything else, but others in my party have and they LOVE the greek salad in particular. If you are in the area this is a solid place to eat, you won't be disappointed.