Fresh & Hot Bagels

UPDATE 11/23/2025: My last review was about three weeks ago and I figured I'd give them another try because I physically went in today. I asked for an Egg everything bagel with VEGGIE cream cheese and ham. I was going to check it before I left but I didn't. I figured, "I'm here,. they couldn't possibly screw it up." WELL, THEY DID. They gave me REGULAR cream cheese and ham. Of course I ate it as I had left work to pick it up and can't go back but COME AWWWWNNNN... I literally told the woman what I wanted. (insert facepalm here). So I will now have to test them and write it down on a piece of paper for them. If they screw it up then, I have lost all hope. ORIGINAL REVIEW 11/09/2025: I've been going here for decades since I've lived in this town for 40 years. However over the las

They mess up food a lot. It's the type of place you should check your food before you leave. The service kind of sucks some of them kind of have attitudes but the atmosphere is okay lol Small place tho and crazily over priced. $10+ for a basic egg sandwich.

This bagel place is a staple of the area, they’ve always had a good deal for high schoolers after class and you have to respect that. Anyone who’s complaining about this place simply doesn’t know how to order a good sandwich. That’s just my opinion.

the older women behind the counter are extremely unpleasant. they screwed up a simple order and apologized in a very sarcastic manner. this place reminds me of middle school, a bunch of means girls who blab away in a foreign language and laugh while talking about others. to save yourself a hassle DOUBLE check your order before you leave, or better yet don’t go here. i do not recommend

We've been coming here for years, but no more. The prices keep increasing and the quality of food is decreasing. I ordered a turkey wrap and was shocked to see it was $13! I figured like most delis on LI, it would at least be overstuffed, nope! It was a few slices of turkey, a slice of cheese, litterally two slices of onion, and stuffed with lettuce. At this point, our favorite local deli is just ripping our community off, and I'm done.