Gambino's Pizza

UPDATE: I appreciate the owner’s reply so I gave two more stars. I do think adding sides that are more toddler friendly (I have three kids ages 2.5 and two at 1, so pizza isn’t the best option for my littlest ones) and allowing for half orders or kids-sized portions would be nice. I wasn’t allowed to half a pasta portion when I asked to, but that would’ve been helpful! We came here during a recent road trip (11/8/25) as it was a local, family-friendly pizza place in Kearney. We had three children under three but who are eating solids. There is no kids menu, and when I asked about that the young girl at the register told me no, and wouldn’t offer any suggestions. I asked if I could order a half pasta order and was told no. I asked if they had milk for kids, she looked at the fountain drin

Typically very, very good! I ordered a $30 pizza...thank goodness it was 1/2 price night. The crust is doughy, center soggy. When I called back to express my concern, as it asks to via the text with the order confirmation. A very nice employee said, I am sorry about that, politely...but no offer to make another one or discount on a future purchase. Kind of disappointing because their pizza is usually amazing...AMAZING and they do have kind staff. I would have appreciated a little...let us make it right for you gesture when I called to express my concern.

2.5 — Pizza was average for its price point. It was fresh off the oven, they had a good amount of toppings, but lacked sauce and flavor. The jalapeño ravioli appetizer was too doughy and it was cold. Had to wait a bit, and seemed like they were understaffed. I was disappointed since I saw a lot of good reviews online.

I ordered a pizza, salad, and a cookie pie. The pizza and salad were fine. But the cookie was delivered with the top super dark and the edges clearly burned (indeed, black in spots). When I called the restaurant to let them know and see if they could deliver a replacement cookie pie, the manager on duty informed me that their cookies are supposed to have blackened edges and dark tops. Apparently charred chocolate chip cookies are normal to him?? He told me that if I didn’t like his response, I was welcome to email the owner who would get back to me at some point. I explained that I am only visiting here in town for one night and really wanted to get this resolved tonight. He had no response except to again reiterate that their cookie pies are supposed to be burned like this. This w

Decent size eat in area, nicely themed and decorated. Workers are courteous and helpful. The pizza is top tier and I'd choose them over a larger chain any day! Havent been in Kearney long but it's def a city wide favorite.