Garfalo's Pizzeria

The steak and cheese pizza is an EXPERIENCE!!! 15/10 It was literally the best steak pizza I’ve ever had… WOW. Will definitely be ordering from here more often! Way to go guys!

Been meaning to try this place for at least a year. That was pretty stupid of me. Cuz it's fantastic. Sheet is thinner than buffalo style, but not by much. Light on the sauce, which is tasty, next time I would ask for some on the side. To dip the crust. An excellent pie, great toppings combinations available. However, the cheese alone, can stand on its own. Only really a standing area, no table service.

Five stars for Gafali's Pizza! As a traveler heading back to Washington state, I made a detour to this Niagara Falls gem based on glowing reviews, and I'm so glad I did. The traditional New York pizza was out of this world – classic, flavorful, and exactly what I was hoping for. Coupled with truly excellent service, this place is a winner. I'd stop again in a heartbeat!

Stopped in for a large pie and wasn't disappointed. Perfect crust and just the right amount of toppings. Easily the best pizza in the area! Highly recommend!

Definitely a disappointment. Pizza was grossly over cooked to the point that the crust was like a cracker and the cheese was all dried out. The entire pizza was almost devoid of moisture. Having worked at a pizzeria in my younger days I can honestly say that we would never have left a pizza like this leave the store unless the customer specifically asked for it to be extra well done. I should have taken pictures to post but we ended up tossing the majority of it in the trash and wrote the $23 off as a bad investment. There are too many great options out there and hopefully the owners will use a bit off common sense quality control in the future before an order goes out the door.