Gelotti Ice Cream

A local ice cream spot loved by residents!!! During the summers, you can see people lined up to the door and parking lot at capacity. Their ice cream is always smooth and creamy; it satisfies all the tastebuds. Definitely a MUST if you’re in Paterson. The Cookie Monster ice cream is always my go-to (pictured left); I ordered the Junior size which is just enough to satisfy my sweet tooth. 10/10! The coconut ice dream (right) is so refreshing and tastes so fresh! A solid ice cream if you love tropical flavors. 9/10

I was craving some ice cream with my family so I came to our favorite local ice cream spot with 30 mins before closing and they started to turn off the lights while we were inside and the second we left around 10:05 they locked the doors denying the costumers that arrived after us. I’d understand if it was 10 5 minutes before closing but 30 is just ridiculous and having the lights turned off felt like we were getting kicked out and rushed.

The ice shop has good ice cream but their customer service will never make you want to go back. The associates act like you’re applying for foodstamps. They are so rude, have absolutely no manners when speaking with a customer. The girl in red hair definitely has no customer service experience.

First time visiting this place. We came a group of 8 trying to escape the hot sun in the morning. I loved the variety they have of Gelatos, Ice cream and cookies. They even have non-dairy options. The place looked super clean. The staff was friendly. I definitely have to come back.

The gelato here is just above average in my opinion. I had a small Tiramisu that tasted more like ice cream. Very nice venue and plenty of parking.