Goldberg's Famous Bagels

Something about these toasted bagels with creme cheese. Very crowded. Couldnt see the line from the main road unlike other locations. Mostly teenagers. Took a while to place our order. I guess we could have chosen the designated bagel only line. Waiting for our order involved a lot of crowd shuffleing. Waiting area and order area are seemingly the same place. So we moved around from spot to spot just to wait for our number to be called. Is it chaotic, i guess. Should i care, no. Lay out is different. Ice coffees arent self serve but have to order at the counter. The bagels. Smells good from the unwrapping. The bagel has a healthy amount of poppy seeds. Good amount of scallions in the very creamy cheese. The bagel is toasted just right. Crispy where it needs to be on the outside, softer

Goldberg’s is a community staple so it’s an obligatory stop. My husband and I stayed across the street at East Hampton House and enjoyed bacon egg and cheese and coffees to go. Overall it’s great! Husband did have a hard time with making the coffee as they didn’t leave enough room for milk lol. It’s a delicious place and location is ideal. 🥯☕️

Always great - everytime we go. We get bagels to take home every time we visit family in Springs. I got a dozen to split between family as small gifts, and the server happily bagged them separately per my request and specs, and bagged my 13th bagel separately for me.

i love goldberg but they always mess up my orders. the other day i got charged for a spinach bagel, it was missing, and then they went on to tell me they don’t sell them anymore. today i order a sesame bagel toasted with butter and american cheese. i specified the type of cheese multiple times. i open my bagel and have a sesame bagel with butter and cream cheese. it’s just frustrating over and over.

I’ve gotten breakfast here every day since I’ve been in the Hamptons. The bagels are delicious. However this morning I ordered a side of turkey bacon and it was burnt to a crisp and inedible. I’ll continue to eat here because of the bagels, but if you are looking for consistency, this isn’t the place.