Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

Dine in. I had the lunch special slice of pizza, extra long breadstick and a drink.$10. Really filling and I have a snack for tonight ( or my dogs devour it). Really convenient location and very friendly staff. Did I mention first time here? I did I think.. I’ll be back!!

If you are looking for a solid slice and a unique atmosphere, this is the place. The pizza is consistently delicious, featuring large slices that are authentic to the style. Do not miss the backroom bar; the lighting and décor create a moody, sophisticated ambiance that feels distinct from the main restaurant. It is an ideal location for a night out.

Best pizza I've ever had! This West coast girl finally understands why you only get a slice and not a whole pie!

Delicious crust and sauce. To be very clear, I had a rough night here, it took awhile to get our pizzas and we were starving, and my pizza was made wrong and had to be remade. And, I’m giving them 5 stars! To be fair, it was Saturday night and it was jam packed with pizzas flying everywhere and I am difficult with no cheese. Alex ate most of his sausage and cheese pizza and enjoyed the rest for breakfast. The staff was exceedingly nice and offered to make it right with a dessert etc. which I didn’t want. I enjoyed the vibes of the restaurant and the reaction in fixing the order was prompt and respectful. We both enjoyed our pizzas and highly recommend this as the spot for pizza in Indy!

Love this place. Hate making reviews like this. Been frequenting this establishment since it opened on Mass Ave. My review is based off your corporate policy (1 star) of not selling things you don’t have available and waiting off to the side. This place is always busy when I go. So sometimes what I order isn’t available. They refuse to sell me something that isn’t in the “window”. It’s always coming though and they tell me to go past the checkout and wait until they have what I want becomes available. It’s happened no lie at least twelve times. Every time I’m waiting and they bring said pizza to the “window”, the ten people in line behind me order the entirety of the newly available pizza while I’m waiting for them to recognize me for what I wanted. Then it’s gone. Pepperoni piz