Goodfellas Pizzeria

Was on vacation at Niagara and was looking for a gluten free pizza, came across mixed reviews for Goodfellas and glad I ordered from here...it was great!! The place wasn't the easiest to find, looked as if it was undergoing remodeling and not a well lit parking lot at our visit. I would recommend delivery instead of pick up for ease, but, super friendly staff and a delicious pie!! Highly recommend!!

I ordered a steak and cheese sub today, told them pacifically how I wanted it. It wasn't the way I asked for it. Took it back they would not refund me and kept my money the sub was HORRIBLE hardly no meat on the sub a pile of onions and banana peppers and the bun was old moldy and hard. They said they would make another one but who wants another sub like that so they got a free 21$. I hope they're happy I would NEVER order from this place AGAIN!!!!! Signed an UNHAPPY CUSTOMER!!!!!

If ever in Niagara Falls a definite stop for great pizza, wings, and salads is this place! The food was really great and freshly made. Because we had a large group we ordered 2 pizzas. First was the classic pepperoni pizza which was super cheesy. Second was with everything in it, and that was great. Both were large pans which have 15 slices each. We also ordered 50 wings, Parmesan/garlic, hot, and mild wings. Of course we tried the antipasto salad which was also really good. Finally an order of dessert bread that was really good. And with all of this food there was plenty to take home. Next visit to Niagara, a definite stop. $$$

Goodfellas used to be a GREAT pizza place, but they have gradually fallen off to the point that I have to write a review after we ordered $180 worth of food. The pizza dough was chewy and had no crisp. The Char-BBQ wings we ordered came just regular BBQ. The Medium wings were burned, dried and lacked sauce. Everything just looked mildly Brown and unappealing. WHAT ARE YOU GUYS DOING? This was the worst pizza order I've had in the Falls area in my 40 years of living here.

This pizza place came highly recommended by a few locals. The restaurant itself needs a bit of TLC, so we ordered take out. The place was crazy busy between phone orders and take away on the week night we were there. Everyone seemed to be ordering wings with their pizza. Our 1/2 tray pizza was huge - it didn’t even fit completely in the box. It was good, reasonably priced. I’m thinking we should have ordered the chicken pizza as looks and sounds amazing. We were told they’ve been in business since 1992, dough is made fresh in house daily. Being from out of town. It was a little hard to find being on a one way street - it’s just off the parking lot behind the McD’s on Pine Avenue.