Goodfella's Pizzeria

Ordered takeout around closing and was unfortunately disappointed. Ordered spaghetti and meatballs, the meatballs were cold but fine otherwise and sauce was extremely watery. Ordered the house pasta and it looked disgusting, didn't even try it maybe it was delicious but I truly couldn't take a bite. The sauce for the house pasta was also really watery. Ordered a side of broccoli and it was again like a soup. Some positives though! Chocolate cake was delicious and we got our order in about 20 minutes after placing it.

It was a Sunday afternoon and my New Yorker parents requested I bring pizza from their favorite place to the house family dinner. At 5:15pm, I called Goodfellas and placed an order for 2 large pizzas - one cheese, one pepperoni. Nothing fancy and asked if I could do a 6:10 pick up. At 6:15, I walked in, paid $40.90 for 2 large pizzas and put a five in the tip jar. Had a nice exchange with the young lady ringing my order up. As she went back to ask for my pizzas, the gentleman reads the order hanging in the line up and then she comes back and says "pizzas are for a 6:10 pick up time." To which I reply, "that's right and it is 6:17." She confers with the fellas making pizzas and says, "it will be 10-15 more minutes for your pizzas." I sat outside for my 15 minutes waiting and I wasn't going

Goodfellas Pizza absolutely delivers. The quality of the food is top-tier—fresh ingredients, perfectly cooked crust, and bold, well-balanced flavors that make every bite worth it. You can genuinely taste the care that goes into their pizza. On top of that, the customer service is excellent: friendly, attentive, and efficient without feeling rushed. It’s the kind of place that makes you want to come back not just for the food, but for the overall experience. Highly recommend if you’re looking for consistently great pizza and service that matches the quality. 🍕🔥

A little over a year ago I tried the baked clams and they were great. Made just the same as I remembered them from an old Italian place n New York I enjoyed as kid. I was happy to find them. I kept reordering them and every time, they got worse and worse. To the point now that they are just all breadcrumb and only one had an actual clam piece in it. For over $16, I think these should now come off the menu. I won’t try to order them again. This is not right to charge for breadcrumbs. Literally. Thank you.

Everyone in my family said this was the best pizza they've ever eaten! I agree! The dough tasted more like fresh French bread than pizza dough! So light and airy! Yet crispy! The toppings were fresh! The cheeses perfect! The sauce amazing! The salad was so fresh and delicious! The garlic rolls were so buttery and so full of garlic!! 5 stars!!! Bravo!! Bellisimo! 😘👌