Goodfella's Pizzeria Sanford

We chose this place because of all the great reviews they have and it was..... GREAT! Our server was absolutely perfect, helpful suggestions, full glasses always, everything you need and funny. The pizza was perfectly baked with a crispy bottom. We will return here again and again and recommend it to everyone!

We had an absolutely wonderful meal. The Lasagna and Ziti Duo and spaghetti/meatballs were delicious. Five stars is not high enough! Great food and service. Highly recommend.

I normally post pictures with my reviews but this is my 3rd time here and I once again forgot to take one because I was too excited to eat and honestly, I'll probably forget again next time but i cant put off a review any more. Please do yourself a favor and eat here. The food is excellent. If you like chicken parm the calzone is incredible and enough to feed two (it is also excellent reheated if you arent willing to share, i dont judge). It isnt just the food tho, every visit we get to chat with Chance who is incredibly sweet and funny. He has recognized us every visit since the first which brings another level of personal to the experience and always seems to be running around helping everyone. Overall wonderful experience every time, would absolutely recommend for any occasion.

Stopped in with my son to try this place out. We ordered the Hawaiian pizza and it was delicious! The cheese tasted so chewy and fresh! We were really impressed with the taste. It was a large and we had enough to take some home so we got two meals out of it. The server Izzy did a great job catering to our needs. The restaurant was clean, and appealing, and the prices were fair. We will definitely return

WOW. Just WOW. Goodfella’s Pizzeria in Sanford completely blew us away!! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warmth, kindness, and the kind of hospitality you dream about. Our server wasn’t just good—he was OUTSTANDING. Genuinely one of the best we’ve ever encountered. His energy, attentiveness, and kindness are the reason we’ll be coming back all the way from Philly—just to experience it again. Now let’s talk food: 🔥 Mozzarella sticks – perfectly crispy on the outside, melty on the inside. 🔥 The wings – flavorful, juicy, and addictive. 🔥 Calzone – cheesy perfection in every bite. 🔥 Pasta for the little one – simple, buttery, comforting. 🔥 Even the lemonade and sweet tea were spot-on. And don’t even get me started on the cannoli—pure bliss. ✨Every single item we ordered wa